Quality perceptions of design journals: The design scholars’ perspectiveGemser, G., De Bont, C., Hekkert, P., & Friedman, K. (2012). Quality perceptions of design journals: The design scholars’ perspective. Design Studies, 33(1), 4-23. doi:10.1016/j.destud.2011.09.001
Abstract: The primary objectives of this study were to identify a set of journals that report on industrial design research and to propose quality rankings of those journals. Based on an online survey, design journals were assessed in terms of two quality metrics: popularity and indexed average rank position. We find that both general and specialized design journals are highly valued and that geographic origin and academic background can be related with journal rankings. The results of the study offer a guide to both evaluators and those evaluated when judging or selecting research outlets.
Keywords: industrial design; evaluation; design research; design science; journal ranking
Appendix. List of journals
We asked respondents to select five journals that they considered being a top tier journal based on the journals’ academic contribution to the industrial design discipline. We furthermore asked respondents to select from the alphabetically ordered list below but emphasized that they could add their own journals in spaces supplied at the bottom of the list. Furthermore, we emphasized that the respondents should select only journals with which they are personally familiar.
1. Applied Ergonomics
2. Creativity and Innovation Management
3. CoDesign
4. Computer-Aided Design
5. Design and Culture
6. Design Issues
7. Design Management Journal
8. Design Philosophy Papers
9. Design Research Quarterly
10. Design Studies
11. Digital Creativity
12. Ergonomics
13. Ergonomics in Design
14. Empirical Studies of the Arts
15. Human-Computer Interaction
16. Human Factors
17. Information Design Journal
18. Interacting with Computers
19. International Journal of Art & Design Education
39. Visible Language
20. International Journal of Design
21. International Journal of Product Development
22. International Journal of Sustainable Design
23. International Journal of Technology and Design Education
24. International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing
25. Journal of Design History
26. Journal of Design Research
27. Journal of Engineering Design
28. Journal of Interior Design
29. Journal of Material Culture
30. Journal of Mechanical Design
31. Journal of Product Innovation Management
32. Journal on Multimodal User Interfaces
33. Materials & Design
34. Personal and Ubiquitous Computing
35. Research in Engineering Design
36. The Design Journal
37. The Journal of Sustainable Product Design
38. The Senses & Society
40. Visual Communication